Sustainable fuels in comparison

Kyrill Kretz
Kyrill Kretz
/ 5 minutes

The transportation sector is under intense pressure: climate targets, rising CO₂ costs, and new legal requirements make it necessary to significantly reduce greenhouse gas emissions—and as quickly as possible. At the same time, many existing vehicle fleets continue to rely on combustion engines.
Against this backdrop, alternative fuels that can at least partially replace fossil diesel are gaining in importance. HVO, biodiesel, and e-fuels are particularly frequently mentioned. All three are considered more climate-friendly alternatives, but differ significantly in terms of market readiness, availability, efficiency, and practical applications.

Kyrill Kretz
Kyrill Kretz
/ 5 minutes

What is HVO? Production and use

HVO (hydrotreated vegetable oil) is a paraffinic diesel fuel produced from vegetable oils and fats. Ideally, waste and residual materials such as used cooking oils or animal fats are used for this purpose. These are treated with hydrogen under high pressure and at high temperatures.

This removes the oxygen from the molecules. The result is a pure hydrocarbon fuel that is chemically very similar to fossil diesel. In further processing steps, HVO is modified to meet the desired properties of a modern diesel fuel.

HVO is usually marketed as HVO100 (pure fuel according to EN 15940) or as an additive to fossil diesel and differs fundamentally from classic biodiesel (FAME).


Where is HVO used?

HVO is considered a market-ready sustainable substitute for diesel and is already available as HVO100 at gas stations in several European countries, particularly in Scandinavia and the Netherlands.

Thanks to its drop-in capability, HVO can be used in approved vehicles without any technical modifications. The existing diesel infrastructure also remains fully usable.

What are the opportunities and risks of HVO?


Opportunities for HVO:

  • Significant CO₂ reduction over the life cycle (often 80–90% for residual materials)
  • Very good fuel quality (high cetane number, good cold behavior, high storage stability)
  • Ready for immediate use in many existing fleets
  • Lower soot and particle emissions


Restrictions on HVO:

  • Limited availability of sustainable raw materials
  • Not a complete substitute for fossil diesel in terms of quantity
  • Generally higher costs than fossil diesel
  • Climate footprint heavily dependent on raw material origin and sustainability certification
Our sustainability

Learn more about our sustainability efforts and discover how we can work together to build a greener future.

What is biodiesel? Production and use

Biodiesel consists of so-called fatty acid methyl esters (FAME). It is produced by chemically converting vegetable oils or fats with methanol. In addition to biodiesel, glycerin is also produced as a by-product. The quality requirements are specified in the standard EN 14214 .

In Europe, biodiesel is mainly produced from rapeseed oil, but also from used cooking oils and animal fats. The properties vary depending on the raw material, for example in terms of behavior in cold conditions or during prolonged storage.


Where is biodiesel used?

Biodiesel has been established for decades and is mainly used as an additive to fossil diesel. The standard fuel B7 contains up to 7% FAME and is approved for almost all diesel vehicles. B100 (pure fuel) is also used in certain fleets, but only with appropriate manufacturer approvals.

What are the opportunities and risks associated with biodiesel?

Opportunities for biodiesel:

  • Technologically mature, with a stable production and supply chain
  • Short-term CO₂ reduction possible through blending
  • Regional value creation, especially in European production
  • Meaningful use of waste and residual materials


Limitations of biodiesel:

  • Poor cold and storage behavior than fossil diesel or HVO
  • Susceptibility to oxidation and hygroscopy (water absorption)
  • Technical limitations with high admixtures
  • Sustainability debates on agricultural biomass (ILUC issue)

What are e-fuels? Production and use

E-fuels are synthetic fuels produced from water and carbon dioxide using electricity. In a process known as power-to-liquid, water is first split into hydrogen and oxygen. The hydrogen then reacts with CO₂, producing a gas mixture that is further processed into liquid fuels.

The result is synthetic variants of diesel, gasoline, or kerosene that are chemically similar to fossil fuels and can basically be used in existing engines.

Deployment, market readiness, opportunities, and limitations

E-fuels are currently still in the early stages of market development. The underlying technology is well known, but has so far mainly been used in pilot and test plants. As a result, the quantities available are low and production costs are very high.

What are the opportunities and risks of e-fuels?

Opportunities for e-fuels:

  • Potentially almost CO₂-neutral when using green electricity
  • High energy density and good storage and transportability
  • Use of existing infrastructure and existing fleets possible
  • Particularly relevant for areas that are difficult to electrify (e.g., aviation, shipping)

 

Restrictions on e-fuels:

  • Very high energy consumption and low overall efficiency
  • Significantly higher costs than fossil fuels or biofuels
  • Dependence on large amounts of renewable energy
  • Limited availability in the medium term, not a mass-market fuel

HVO vs. biodiesel vs. e-fuels

For better classification, the following overview shows the most important differences at a glance and clearly illustrates what these mean in everyday use.

HVO
biodiesel
e-fuels
CO₂ reduction potential
High, when using waste and residual materials
Medium to high, depending on the raw material
Very high, theoretically almost climate neutral
raw material base
Used cooking oils, animal fats, residues
Vegetable oils (e.g., rapeseed), used fats
Renewable electricity, water, CO₂
Engine compatibility
High: immediately usable in approved diesel engines (drop-in)
Limited: Standard only up to B7, B100 only with approval
High potential: technically compatible, currently hardly available
infrastructure
Existing diesel infrastructure can be used (gas stations, storage facilities, logistics)
Existing diesel infrastructure can be utilized
Existing infrastructure fundamentally usable, currently hardly any supply
Costs
Higher than fossil diesel
Moderate, close to fossil diesel
Very high due to energy-intensive manufacturing
scalability
Limited by available sustainable raw materials
Limited by raw material availability and sustainability requirements
Severely limited by power requirements and production capacities
market readiness
High: commercially available
Very high: established for years
Low: Pilot and demonstration phase

Which fuel is the best?

There is no single "best" sustainable fuel. The most appropriate solution depends on the time frame, the specific area of application, and the economic conditions.

  • HVO is currently the most practical option for making existing vehicle fleets more climate-friendly in the short term and without technical retrofitting.

  • Biodiesel remains a proven transitional solution, especially in the form of blends, but reaches its technical and ecological limits at higher proportions.

  • E-fuels are primarily a strategic option for the future, especially for applications where direct electrification is hardly possible.

For companies and transport operators, the following therefore applies: sustainable fuels are no substitute for fundamental systemic change, but they are an important building block for reducing emissions in the short term and in a targeted manner.

Our services

Drive more sustainably now and discover our modern vehicle fleet.

Our customers

Trust us, just like these satisfied private individuals and companies. Together we have organized great events with buses and our other services.

Verified
customer reviews
via ProvenExpert

Verified
customer reviews
via ProvenExpert

Our bus world

In our agt Bus World, we provide information about current developments in our company, as well as the latest topics and events in the bus and mobility industry.

In our agt Bus World, we provide information about current developments in our company, as well as the latest topics and events in the bus and mobility industry.

Report misconduct

As soon as you become aware of incidents or business practices of AGT Bus- & Eventlogistik GmbH where you have doubts as to whether they are in accordance with the legal regulations, the Code of Conduct or other guidelines of AGT Bus- & Eventlogistik GmbH, you can report them now.

Not only the support of employees, but also the assistance of customers and business partners is of great importance. This is the only way to react immediately and avert or minimize damage. Ideally, the problem should be discussed directly and confidentially with a contact person at AGT Bus- & Eventlogistik GmbH. In this way, a solution can be found quickly and without detours.

However, there may be situations in which this direct route does not appear feasible. In such cases, a specialized legal ombudsman (lawyer of trust) has been set up as an internal and external reporting office at AGT Bus- & Eventlogistik GmbH. The information will be received confidentially. The reporting person can communicate openly with the ombudsman, stating their name and contact details. This makes it possible to ask questions about the facts of the case, which sometimes proves to be very helpful. If desired, however, the identity of the person making the report will not be disclosed.

If you do not wish to disclose your identity to the lawyer of confidence, you can submit information online and anonymously via the following whistleblower portal. Anonymous tips will also be investigated.

It is trusted that no information will be submitted with dishonest intent. False reports can have legal consequences. With the help of this reporting system, AGT Bus- & Eventlogistik GmbH ensures that every report is carefully checked and that the reporter does not suffer any disadvantages as a result.

The attorney of trust of AGT Bus- & Eventlogistik GmbH can be reached at the following contact details:

Compliance Officer Services Legal

Attorney Stephan Rheinwalt
Telemannstrafle 22
53173 Bonn
s.rheinwald@cos-legal.eu
Tel.: 0228/ 35036291
Mobile: 0171/7722906
Fax: 0228/ 35036292